shinyhalo wrote:Lamellar. I made one of these tunics. It looks great. I have tried three different lacing methods. Horizontals tight, verticals loose. All tight. All loose. The problem is it just won't hold up in a war against someone as strong as me (and the sad truth is that there are a lot of people stronger than me). The lamellae bend inward too much under a man's strength. Period. I don't care how awesome someone thinks their lamellar is. Even a half strength thrust with a 2" head spear can crack those ribs through it. I'd use it for screwing around or one vs one vs a 1-H sword, but I wouldn't fight a 2Hander sword with it. Clavicles go bye bye.
I don't know what lamellar you are wearing but my experience has been very different. I wore metal lamellar from 1992-2008, and I rarely if ever had an issue with a lamellae bending, and certainly never had an issue with my ribs or clavicles- if you know me, I am not a big guy at all. I've also fought plenty of great weapon and spear, and been hit by big guys like Bytor and Balfar, and hard hitters like Michael of Bedford and never had an issue.
I think you constructed your lamellar incorrectly, maybe. Also, there are many different ways to strap it on so to speak. I used wide leather shoulder straps that I re-inforced with plastic. They worked very well, and I never have had a clavicle issue.
I find it odd that my experience with lamellar is so completely different from yours, and the Kingdoms and fighters I was playing in/with are generally recognized as significantly harder hitting ones than the average guy in your area.
shinyhalo wrote:Hockey stuff fits great and functions great. I have some of it too. The torso stuff I can hide easily. But...I can't even imagine how to hide full hockey arms without overheating from so many layers or restricting my movement from garb-over-armor syndrome and frankly garb-over-armor looks awful. I don't need to look fucking awesome, but I'd to look good.
Wear the hockey arms, and a linen shirt with loose fitting sleeves. I've won 2 crowns doing this, and never had an issue with overheating (lived in the Carolinas and Southern California), and certainly not with any movement restrictions.
In these two great action shots by Ursus the Awesome, you can see that I have little or no movement restriction or garb over armor problems from the hockey arms I am wearing. I don't look f'ing awesome, but my gear looks pretty ok:
http://www.bogpages.com/SCA-photographs ... 4fm4F-A-LBhttp://www.bogpages.com/SCA-photographs ... 2599-M.jpgshinyhalo wrote:Aluminum is ok. Just ok. I have a ton of it. Repeated blows to aluminum turn it into mush. Really, it's fascinating. I have an aluminum shield that makes people cringe because it's so warped. It's not a good long term solution, but it's a good rigid material for coming up with prototypes and patterns.
Then you are using some odd alloy or a low temper aluminum. T0-T3 aluminum will bend in your hands easily. T6 6061 or 7075 will hold up to SCA combat virtually forever, and will likely crack along a stress line before denting. If I am correct it has a tensile strength similar to 1050 hardened spring steel. The aluminum you are using is not the right stuff for combat. (If you or anyone else is really "with it" buy T0 6061 work it into the shape you want and then temper it to T6...). Same goes for your shield, it's made from the wrong alloy/wrong temper and probably too thin. My kite shield is 14 years old and has no dents in it. In the Eastern Crown video I just saw, it looked like Gregor is using the same shield he had when I met him in 1993. He fights at a big practice all the time, and it hasn't dented, bent or warped.
Look out for bad aluminum. Make sure you get T6 6061 or 7075. It'll last forever.
shinyhalo wrote:Wearing pants over armor...heh. This is a problem for Florida. Here is how it breaks down. Clothing over armor blocks airflow, weighs, and provides zero padding. Then comes the hard shell under it adding weight, more airflow restriction, and still zero padding. So then you add padding, adding more airflow restriction and a nice layer of insulation. So you look like a pillsbury dough boy and dehydrate. There are some garb-over-armor combos that are passable. Like stripped down old-school lacross shoulders, but even they give people that football player look.
Here's how it breaks down: What a Wussy BS argument. I started fighting in Columbia SC, where the average temperature, is 2 degrees HIGHER than Destin FL, and the humidity is about the same. I currently live in Charlotte, NC, where the average temp is only 3-4 degrees lower than Destin with similar amounts of humidity. I am so tired of you Floridians and other whining about the temperature. It's a load of CRAP. Other places are as hot and humid, and we wear armor and clothing and don't bitch.
Here's a shot of me in my lamellar (Again from the Mighty Ursus!):
http://www.bogpages.com/SCA-photographs ... Jn-M-1.jpgMy legs don't look dough boyish, do they?? Also, my arm seems to be moving quite well despite the fact that I am wearing a shirt over hockey arms.
BTW let me tell you and anyone else who uses this "temperature argument" something: stop being a wuss. Man up and wear some armor and clothing. Make it out of the right materials so you don't bake. And then WORK OUT SOME and GET IN SHAPE. Plenty of people from all over the country wear the right stuff in places where it's hot. Wearing pants over armor is not a problem for Florida- plenty of people do it there and don't die, and fight well.shinyhalo wrote: Gorgets are pretty easy. I've got this good. The neck doesn't get whipped around as fast as the arms AND it has stops at either end of it.
The slash guards are interesting, but difficult to hide. I have arms figured out though. I have come to the conclusion that a steel elbow cop attached to both a wide-splint vambrace and a sticky rerbrace is the best. By sticky I mean that the material is soft and adheres and wedges itself into the flesh so the whole thing doesn't come flying off when you swing.
Sounds like an unwieldy solution, but hey, whatever works for you.
shinyhalo wrote:Like I said before, I am close to a good kit for Florida, but thanks for the ideas.
"Florida" is not an excuse for not wearing good armor. People from "hot zones" all over the country wear the right stuff and fight at top levels while looking good.
g-