mid-15th C Rondel dagger

For those of us who wish to talk about the many styles and facets of recreating Medieval armed combat.
Post Reply
User avatar
J.G.Elmslie
Archive Member
Posts: 1208
Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:03 am
Location: Edinburgh / Inverness, Scotland
Contact:

mid-15th C Rondel dagger

Post by J.G.Elmslie »

thought people might enjoy this... done for myself rather than a client, for once...

Bronze hilt components with a through tang and cord-bound grip (done to match a similar dated longsword), blade is forged carbon steel, appleseed reinforced tip for thrusting, scabbard with wool lining...

length of blade is 11 inches.

Dying is slightly blotchy under flash, but perfectly even under sunlight.
came out quite nicely, I think.

and the pics...

Front:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel01s.jpg

Back:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel02.jpg

Unsheathed:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel03.jpg

Reinforced tip:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel04.jpg

Peined through construction with graved lines:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel05.jpg

not too badly made, if I do say so myself...

someday, I need to get someone wanting hollowground triangular section rondels made. I'd rather like to make more of these...
Previously known as Suzerain.

http://www.elmslie.co.uk
Baron Alcyoneus
Archive Member
Posts: 39578
Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2008 7:00 pm

Post by Baron Alcyoneus »

How much was this, and how much for the one you want to make?
Vypadni z mého trávník!

Does loyalty trump truth?

"If they hurt you, hurt them back. If they kill you, walk it off."- Captain America
User avatar
J.G.Elmslie
Archive Member
Posts: 1208
Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:03 am
Location: Edinburgh / Inverness, Scotland
Contact:

Post by J.G.Elmslie »

How much was this one?
hrm, would you beleive me if I told you that technically, about $10 - yes, that's not a type, ten dollars...

It was specifically made for myself for fun on weekends, using spare bits of stock - the blade was an offcut section and originally done as a practice peice in hot-working steel and basic shaping, since I usually use stock removal techniques.
The bronze plates were offcuts from a 16th C rapier hangar project that I had gathering dust, the scabbard chape was a section of scrap from a customer's chape, which was *just* big enough to squeeze a chape out of.
The scabbard core, likewise, were the offcuts of limewood from a single-handed sword scabbard that was done, and the wool core was two spare bits that were too small for sword scabbard linings.
The grip was a spare length of ash from when I was making pollaxes, sawn to size and bored through.
Even the leather for the scabbard was a bit left over from other projects that I'd had lying around and was of an odd shape I'd never really use for anything else.

Once I started realising I had most of the bits lying around as offcuts, I really started specifically trying to do it as a challenge for myself to see how high a quality peice I could make just using up stuff I had in my bits box, for the hell of it.

Only things I bought for it specifically was a reel of linen thread, as I'd run out, and a load of emery paper for the polishing work.



For the ones I'd like to make its dependant on details of course, but I'm suspecting that I'd go for EN45 steel with stock removal if it were a commercial peice, as that way I could have them heat-treated by an outsourced contractor, same as I would with longswords - far better than doing it myself as my heat-treatment kit is rather crude, and ensures absolute quality.
and then well, I'm sort of split between the really long bladed early 15th C types, and the shorter ones of the early 16th C. I'm tempted by doing an english black horn handled dagger with slab-sides riveted to a wide hilt, with 3-layer laminate blackwood and either silver or steel hilt components, with the basic proportions based off this one in the wallace collection... I'm guessing an approximate pricetag for that of around £180-200 depending on complexity and materials used. I'm hoping for steel or silver, as I'm getting sick of making bronze hilted stuff... I want some stuff that is'nt yellow! :)

sorry, I'm geeking now, I'll shut up.

erm, here's a pic of the wallace collection #A726 and #A729 daggers from the 1400's and early 1500's respectively that I'd like to base the blades off.
Attachments
France c. 1400 - c. 1450
<br />Steel, copper alloy and wood, inlaid
<br />Blade length: 39.4 cm
<br />Weight: 0.41 kg
France c. 1400 - c. 1450
Steel, copper alloy and wood, inlaid
Blade length: 39.4 cm
Weight: 0.41 kg
A726 1400-50.jpg (42.84 KiB) Viewed 259 times
Germany, 1st half of 16th century, Iron or steel, wood and leather, filed and tooled.
<br />Blade length: 27.3 cm x 1.3cm, Weight: 0.21 kg
Germany, 1st half of 16th century, Iron or steel, wood and leather, filed and tooled.
Blade length: 27.3 cm x 1.3cm, Weight: 0.21 kg
A729 1500-50.jpg (49.62 KiB) Viewed 259 times
Previously known as Suzerain.

http://www.elmslie.co.uk
Destichado
Archive Member
Posts: 5623
Joined: Mon Oct 23, 2000 1:01 am

Post by Destichado »

Very, very well done.

It's *so* well done that, one bladesmith to another, I feel comfortable giving you a little hell over it. :P

So seriously, what's with that choil?

You make this awesome weapon that looks like a period piece ...until you draw the blade? Nah, you know your archaeology of weapons too well for it to be sloppy research. So what happened? Finish the blade before you figured out what you were making? ;)
Memento, homo, quod cinis es! Et in cenerem reverentis!
User avatar
J.G.Elmslie
Archive Member
Posts: 1208
Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:03 am
Location: Edinburgh / Inverness, Scotland
Contact:

Post by J.G.Elmslie »

Destichado wrote:Very, very well done.

It's *so* well done that, one bladesmith to another, I feel comfortable giving you a little hell over it. :P

So seriously, what's with that choil?

You make this awesome weapon that looks like a period piece ...until you draw the blade? Nah, you know your archaeology of weapons too well for it to be sloppy research. So what happened? Finish the blade before you figured out what you were making? ;)


Heh, I think the phrase I'm looking for at this point is "it's a fair cop, guv'ner, you got me..."

I originally did the drawing out when I was just using the offcut peice for practice work, with no serious intention of making it into a peice, just the vague intention of trying to do the shape of an 16th/early 17th C scots dudgeon dagger, based off a couple of samples in the scottish national museum, which have a fairly pronounced choil/ricasso which was engraved and inlaid in gold.

I decided that the handle for that, made in fruitwood was a bit crappy, I was'nt getting the facets carved right, and decided if I was going to do a dudgeon dagger, I'd do it in boxwood, and make it right (also have a slightly thicker distal profile, I found on handling originals.

Hence deciding to just use it as a practice peice and use stuff lying around. I should've just done stock removal and taken the ricasso out when I decided to go for a rondel dagger (would've removed some messy marks on the flats if I had), but I decided it was better to keep it as it is, and I can always make something better next time

the fact that you say " one bladesmith to another" makes me laugh and feel utterly amazed, though. I'm no-where *near* being able to be considered in te same league as you guys, particularly for hot-working. that one is literally only the third one I've ever done with drawing out and my own heat-treatment. I know I'm semi-competent at stock removal and a good cutler for swordhilts, but I'm still a rank amateur at making blades.

the harsh critique is certainly appreciated!

next time I'm going to have to do a proper rondel... and a *good* dudgeon dagger too. :)
Previously known as Suzerain.

http://www.elmslie.co.uk
User avatar
sha-ul
Archive Member
Posts: 10636
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 4:16 pm
Location: barony of vatavia,calontir, west of Wichita
Contact:

Re: mid-15th C Rondel dagger

Post by sha-ul »

Suzerain wrote:thought people might enjoy this... done for myself rather than a client, for once...

Bronze hilt components with a through tang and cord-bound grip (done to match a similar dated longsword), blade is forged carbon steel, appleseed reinforced tip for thrusting, scabbard with wool lining...

length of blade is 11 inches.

Dying is slightly blotchy under flash, but perfectly even under sunlight.
came out quite nicely, I think.

and the pics...

Front:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel01s.jpg

Back:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel02.jpg

Unsheathed:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel03.jpg

Reinforced tip:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel04.jpg

Peined through construction with graved lines:
Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Rondel05.jpg

not too badly made, if I do say so myself...

someday, I need to get someone wanting hollowground triangular section rondels made. I'd rather like to make more of these...


Alright, you have convinced me, SOLD!!! :wink:
Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience
User avatar
J.G.Elmslie
Archive Member
Posts: 1208
Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:03 am
Location: Edinburgh / Inverness, Scotland
Contact:

Re: mid-15th C Rondel dagger

Post by J.G.Elmslie »

sha-ul wrote:Alright, you have convinced me, SOLD!!! :wink:


:D

actually, that rather raises a question I should ask for opinions on...

I'm in the process of getting a website up and running for selling stuff like this...

would people say its better to have samples of everything produced in the past, and sell products as "ask me for what you want made" comissions, or would it be good to have a few peices like this in stock and marked "For Sale" with price tags, as well?

dont really know for sure what looks best for such a site, so would appreciate opinions.

and meanwhile, one that's just having its hilt parts cast as I type.

Image
http://3dfolio.com/jge/Nicky_Version2_Masters.jpg for a larger shot
Previously known as Suzerain.

http://www.elmslie.co.uk
Destichado
Archive Member
Posts: 5623
Joined: Mon Oct 23, 2000 1:01 am

Post by Destichado »

Why the hell do you have to live across the pond? -_-
I love making blades, but I lose interest and drag out the project when I have to mount them. And you're so damn good at it!

I think it would be nice if you had a spot for in-stock items, but I certainly don't think it's necessary. If you're going to get into this, look at the best. That pretty much means Christian Fletcher, since he more or less broke in the idea of being a custom cutler to famous blade makers (ATrim primarily, Albion -and others- later).
He does have an in-stock page. There's not much on it.
Memento, homo, quod cinis es! Et in cenerem reverentis!
Post Reply