Video is an unforgiving critic

For those of us who wish to talk about the many styles and facets of recreating Medieval armed combat.
Post Reply
User avatar
Fearghus Macildubh
Archive Member
Posts: 3364
Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2000 1:01 am
Location: Bellevue, WA. USA

Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Fearghus Macildubh »

Went to my second practice after a long break(see the post below about getting back in armour). The knights running the practice videotape the fights so we can dissect them after. Man, the tape will show you the truth about your fighting as compared to the picture your brain has. I was fighting axe and sword and getting pasted, I thought because my opponent was much taller than me and I'm not used to that, plus he's a knight. The other knights told me that I was not moving the axe out to the side meet his attacks, but posting it straight in front of me, making a nice fulcrum for wraps. I filed the info and thought I did better against the other unbelted fighter because I was blocking correctly.

Cut to video. Nope, I was doing the same thing, popping a thrust then holding the axe in straight front of myself. I was also beating the crap out of everyone's shields.

Looks like it's back to basics for Fearghus. Sword and board. Drill, baby drill!
Last edited by Fearghus Macildubh on Mon Jul 02, 2012 9:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Cheers,
Fearghus
Man-at-arms to Sir Aethelred Cloudbreaker
User avatar
Thomas MacFinn
Archive Member
Posts: 2830
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 12:51 pm
Location: Louisville, KY
Contact:

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Thomas MacFinn »

Fearghus Macildubh wrote:...
Looks like it's back to basics ...
Funny how often that happens to all of us. ;)
I never stay in one place for three of my opponent's blows. I also never let my opponent throw three unanswered blows. Standing in front of your opponent lets him perfect his pell technique. Most fighters are very good against a pell. - Duke Gyrth
User avatar
Thorstenn
Archive Member
Posts: 2131
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 2:01 am
Location: Barony of Oldenfeld, Trimaris.

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Thorstenn »

Video is a harsh mistress indeed, that's why I love to utilize it as much as possible. It will see everything and not lie or candy coat it at all. Good luck in getting back into the swing of things.

Thor-
Duke Thorstenn the WrongHand
Trimaris.

"A fully equipped duke costs as much to keep up as two Dreadnoughts, and dukes are just as great a terror -- and they last longer."
David Lloyd George

"Amat victoria curam."
Payn
Archive Member
Posts: 2663
Joined: Thu Jan 04, 2001 2:01 am
Location: Seattle, Wa

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Payn »

Video makes for all sorts of fun. I have to re-think everything I felt when watching video, cause man oh man can a person look thick.
SCA Payn D'Spencer Of Warboys. Barony of Madrone. Giving hope to the squires of AnTir.
MKA Ted Zimmers

French Warfare... A knife fight followed by a track meet
losthelm
Archive Member
Posts: 12207
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2000 1:01 am
Location: albion NY half way between rochester/buffalo
Contact:

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by losthelm »

I find slow work helps alot with foot work and positioning problems.
Wilhelm Smydle in the SCA

My Ebay Listings
My ETSY
User avatar
Fearghus Macildubh
Archive Member
Posts: 3364
Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2000 1:01 am
Location: Bellevue, WA. USA

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Fearghus Macildubh »

I have to make a pell where I can better work in the round to practice with angles. I move in a T when I should be moving in a V or M. If I want to improve, I'll have to do more than helm up and go hit things at practice.
Cheers,
Fearghus
Man-at-arms to Sir Aethelred Cloudbreaker
Kilkenny
Archive Member
Posts: 12021
Joined: Sun Oct 06, 2002 1:01 am
Location: NJ
Contact:

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Kilkenny »

Fearghus Macildubh wrote:I have to make a pell where I can better work in the round to practice with angles. I move in a T when I should be moving in a V or M. If I want to improve, I'll have to do more than helm up and go hit things at practice.
Visualize. It's an under utilized tool of amazing power. You can play a fight in your mind, stop action and evaluate what is going to happen next, back up and try a different technique when the first one doesn't work - all without annoying your opponent or getting bruises ;)

If you are having a problem like holding your second weapon straight out in front instead of where it ought to be, you can work on correcting that by replaying the fights where you were holding it wrong, but this time, make the correction. Check it several times as you're going through the replay. And by replay, I'm referring to the mental replay where you visualize the fight.

On one particular occasion, I was training for a Crown tourney. The week before in another tourney I lost a bout to someone who quite neatly handed me my head. Over the intervening week I replayed that fight numerous times, until I found a version where he did everything that had worked so very well, only it got him killed instead of me ;) When we met in Crown, he did what had worked so well the week before - I did what I had visualized. The result was a flawless victory for me.
Gavin Kilkenny
Proprietor
Noble Lion Leather
hardened leather armour and sundry leather goods
www.noblelionleather.com
User avatar
dukelogan
Archive Member
Posts: 5581
Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2002 1:01 am
Location: leading the downward spiral
Contact:

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by dukelogan »

true true true to the most truest! always try to video all of you fights, then watch them over and over. first, watch the "show". meaning just watch it, dont study it. then pick it apart. i start with watching my opponents reaction to my every move. i do this in slow motion (all studying is in slow motion to being with). then i watch my reaction to their every move. then watch whatever, and watch it again and again picking something new to look at each time (could be shot selection, could be head movement, could be footwork, etc). i spent more time watching my sparring videos in boxing than i actually sparred. trust me, it helps.

and i echo my brother in wishing you the best of luck getting back into the swing of things. having been out from injury for almost three years myself i can tell you when they say "its like riding a bike" makes sense but feels like bs. it really is a never ending learning skill.

regards
logan
Thorstenn wrote:Video is a harsh mistress indeed, that's why I love to utilize it as much as possible. It will see everything and not lie or candy coat it at all. Good luck in getting back into the swing of things.

Thor-
Ebonwoulfe Armory is fully stocked with spears again! For now the only way to order them is to send an email to ebonwoulfearmory@gmail.com with the quantity and your shipping address. We will send a PayPal invoice in response including your shipping cost.
User avatar
William de Faleston
Archive Member
Posts: 631
Joined: Fri Jan 02, 2004 2:01 am
Location: Pumpkin Center, NC

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by William de Faleston »

If you think regular video is bad, get ahold of a camera that shoots high framerate slow motion. I filmed myself in slo-mo Doug flat snaps on the Oslo shortly after I got my cast off from breaking my sword arm. It was the ugliest, most awkward thing I had ever seen. Very instructive though.
"Despite your use of all caps, I don't believe that you are correct." - Kilkenny
Jestyr
Archive Member
Posts: 1942
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2008 5:17 pm
Location: Trimaris / South Florida
Contact:

Re: Video is an unforgiving critic

Post by Jestyr »

dukelogan wrote:i spent more time watching my sparring videos in boxing than i actually sparred.
Yeah, but that is because you are narcissistic. ;-)
Custom Chainmail!
Get custom-sized, flat-ring, riveted chainmail at a great price! www.customchainmail.com!

Email me at sales@customchainmail.com for more information.
Post Reply