Does anyone here on the board do Waterjet cutting or know someone fairly well that does? Plasma and Laser would not be an option due to the heating of the spring stainless steel.
I'm contemplating making an item for sale, but I need to have a rough idea of the cost to know if it would be worth it.
Initially I'm imagining a single prototype of a design cut into a sheet of 2' x 4' 410 stainless steel in 18 gauge. If the cost would be the same, maybe several sheets of 410 stacked on top of one another.
No, I don't have the design in a CAD file yet, because that would involve a considerable amount of work and I don't want to go that far if it would be cost prohibitive.
If anyone can help, I would appreciate it. Thanks!
Water Jet Cutting?
- Vermillion
- Archive Member
- Posts: 791
- Joined: Tue Feb 14, 2006 1:32 pm
- Location: West "by God" Virginia
Water Jet Cutting?
Vermillion On the Archive
Christian Von Beckner In the Society
---------------------------
"Pro Deus et mi Patris"
Christian Von Beckner In the Society
---------------------------
"Pro Deus et mi Patris"
- PatternWeld
- Archive Member
- Posts: 2230
- Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2008 6:31 pm
- Location: Al-Sahid, Caid
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
Talk to Jamie @ Polarbear Forge
Jonathan Baird wrote: If the way were meant to be easy it would teach you no lesson.
Rhyance wrote:Seek excellence the way a man with his hair on fire seeks a pond. Rinse and repeat. Every day.
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
Scott at Darkwood Armory does commission work with his water jet.
Uric
Uric
The monkey must come out!
-
losthelm
- Archive Member
- Posts: 12207
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2000 1:01 am
- Location: albion NY half way between rochester/buffalo
- Contact:
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
Are you sure the 410 is heat treated?
Plasma would save a bit of money if you don't mind a little cleanup.
Plasma would save a bit of money if you don't mind a little cleanup.
- polarbearforge
- Archive Member
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Sat Oct 19, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: South Dakota
- Contact:
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
I run a laser and cutting 18g spring stainless is not a problem. When I had a good supplier, I made lamellar plates this way out of 20g.
For just about anybody, you'll need to have a cad file for a quote to be made. When I quote things, I need to know runtime, and I need a cad file to do it.
Jamie
For just about anybody, you'll need to have a cad file for a quote to be made. When I quote things, I need to know runtime, and I need a cad file to do it.
Jamie
Jamie
Polar Bear Forge
Custom knives - Laser Cut Lamellar Plates - Coat of plates kit - Grinder in a box kit - Tong blanks - Valsgarde Helm kit - Gauntlet kit
Polar Bear Forge
Custom knives - Laser Cut Lamellar Plates - Coat of plates kit - Grinder in a box kit - Tong blanks - Valsgarde Helm kit - Gauntlet kit
- Jofthepeace
- Archive Member
- Posts: 822
- Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2006 11:58 am
- Location: Indiana
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
Pretty much what Jamie said about the quoting. Though the 18 gage will cut very quickly, it will still be fast if they are stacked 5 to 6 thick as well.polarbearforge wrote:I run a laser and cutting 18g spring stainless is not a problem. When I had a good supplier, I made lamellar plates this way out of 20g.
For just about anybody, you'll need to have a cad file for a quote to be made. When I quote things, I need to know runtime, and I need a cad file to do it.
Jamie
My work has a waterjet that I'll do shields out of occasionally.
The fact that the price must be paid is proof it is worth paying.
If you plan for the worst, all surprises are pleasant.
If you plan for the worst, all surprises are pleasant.
- Ingelri
- Archive Member
- Posts: 833
- Joined: Wed Mar 22, 2006 2:33 pm
- Location: Barony of Bryn Madoc, Bethlehem, GA
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
Since I would assume that you are cutting and forming before heat treating, I wouldn't think that using a laser or plasma would make that much of a difference. Most 410 Stainless is annealed when you get it. Now, if it's the opposite, and the piece has already been heat treated, then yes waterjet would probably be a better option.
Mike Johnson
Argent Fleur Armoury
__________________________
Baron Ingelri Kelvin, OVO
Barony of Bryn Madoc, Meridies
Argent Fleur Armoury
__________________________
Baron Ingelri Kelvin, OVO
Barony of Bryn Madoc, Meridies
- Vermillion
- Archive Member
- Posts: 791
- Joined: Tue Feb 14, 2006 1:32 pm
- Location: West "by God" Virginia
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
No the pieces have not already been heat treated.
My concern with plasma was too much mess, and with a lot of small cuts to what is a fairly small piece, the clean up time and final polish would make the whole thing NOT cost effective.
My concern with Laser would be that it would cause some unintended heat treatment to the 410, and again cause the forming stage to be much more of a PITA. 410 is kinda wonky this way, and some of the people who work with 1050 that I've talked too have reported similar issues when they do hot work with it. But since I have my own kiln, I guess I could just anneal it again. *dohhhhh* Sometimes I miss the obvious.
So that is how I can to the Water Jet decision.... Now I see that I'm probably in error. That is why I ask my friends here for advice before I do stupid things
Jamie, I'll be in touch, but it might be a month or two. I will try to work up a dxf before I contact you.
To everyone... I don't mean to be mysterious about my intent, but my idea is basically for an item that would be a low volume, moderate profit item, that could easily be copied and "stolen" by many of the more established vendors around the community. So you can understand why I wish to be "mysterious" at this point.
My concern with plasma was too much mess, and with a lot of small cuts to what is a fairly small piece, the clean up time and final polish would make the whole thing NOT cost effective.
My concern with Laser would be that it would cause some unintended heat treatment to the 410, and again cause the forming stage to be much more of a PITA. 410 is kinda wonky this way, and some of the people who work with 1050 that I've talked too have reported similar issues when they do hot work with it. But since I have my own kiln, I guess I could just anneal it again. *dohhhhh* Sometimes I miss the obvious.
So that is how I can to the Water Jet decision.... Now I see that I'm probably in error. That is why I ask my friends here for advice before I do stupid things
Jamie, I'll be in touch, but it might be a month or two. I will try to work up a dxf before I contact you.
To everyone... I don't mean to be mysterious about my intent, but my idea is basically for an item that would be a low volume, moderate profit item, that could easily be copied and "stolen" by many of the more established vendors around the community. So you can understand why I wish to be "mysterious" at this point.
Vermillion On the Archive
Christian Von Beckner In the Society
---------------------------
"Pro Deus et mi Patris"
Christian Von Beckner In the Society
---------------------------
"Pro Deus et mi Patris"
- polarbearforge
- Archive Member
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Sat Oct 19, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: South Dakota
- Contact:
Re: Water Jet Cutting?
The amount of heat affected zone on 18g would be negligible. It would not cause you any problems.
If you want to send me a drawing, I can give suggestions/advice regarding the part.
Jamie
If you want to send me a drawing, I can give suggestions/advice regarding the part.
Jamie
Jamie
Polar Bear Forge
Custom knives - Laser Cut Lamellar Plates - Coat of plates kit - Grinder in a box kit - Tong blanks - Valsgarde Helm kit - Gauntlet kit
Polar Bear Forge
Custom knives - Laser Cut Lamellar Plates - Coat of plates kit - Grinder in a box kit - Tong blanks - Valsgarde Helm kit - Gauntlet kit
