Great helm found in Moravia?
- Roland Ansbacher
- Archive Member
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2000 1:01 am
- Location: Coeur d'Alene
- Contact:
Great helm found in Moravia?
Neat little article on a metal detector find in Moravia.
Honestly, it's probably the best written and most comprehensive article on armor I've seen in a long while.
Good photos too!
http://www.academia.edu/2909994/A_Uniqu ... in_Moravia
Honestly, it's probably the best written and most comprehensive article on armor I've seen in a long while.
Good photos too!
http://www.academia.edu/2909994/A_Uniqu ... in_Moravia
- Ironbadger
- Archive Member
- Posts: 3445
- Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 2:39 pm
- Location: Anaheim, southern California
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Very nice.
I've been thinking about making a 5 piece greathelm for a while.
-Badger-
I've been thinking about making a 5 piece greathelm for a while.
-Badger-
Maker of sharp and pointy things!
- RandallMoffett
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4613
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: SE Iowa
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Very, very cool.
That one they show looks sort of like the MAc Bible helm.
RPM
That one they show looks sort of like the MAc Bible helm.
RPM
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 492
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 7:43 am
- Location: minnesota-rivenwoodtower
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Awsome, I love the interior pics of the rivets. On page 104 in the upper right figure the great helm in that immage appears to be made of lots of plates (more than I have seen on any other construction). Is this right?
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4942
- Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2004 2:34 pm
- Location: Dinuba, CA
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
It's much more akin to the early Manesse Codex imagery, the Madeln I and Dargen helms, all of which are dated to the earliest decades of the 14th century.RandallMoffett wrote:That one they show looks sort of like the MAc Bible helm.
-Gerhard
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 959
- Joined: Thu Aug 10, 2000 1:01 am
- Location: Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I don't like the assumption that the owner used it for target practice to explain the number of punctures from battle damage. The author says this even after confirming another helmet was worn under it. I think it is very plausible that the damage was the result of numerous strikes that were not lethal during the same battle. Otherwise, it is a very well written and thorough article.
Aelric
Aelric
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Sadly we will never know, but I appreciate that they didn't look for the stunning awesome effect of saying that the helm was surely damaged in a combat. Archeology, and history should stick to facts, and not to assumptions to raise more interest around it.
- RandallMoffett
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4613
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: SE Iowa
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Greg,
Not the helm the just found but one in the paper.
RPM
Not the helm the just found but one in the paper.
RPM
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4942
- Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2004 2:34 pm
- Location: Dinuba, CA
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Oh, they show a lot of them... Which one in particular?
-Gerhard
-Gerhard
- Effingham
- Archive Member
- Posts: 15102
- Joined: Sat Aug 19, 2000 1:01 am
- Location: Franklin, IN USA
- Contact:
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
As I look at that helm, I find myself immediately thinking, "Prank, without the wrapper."
Webpage: http://www.sengokudaimyo.com
Custom avatars: http://sengokudaimyo.com/avatarbiz.html
SENGOKU DAIMYO ONLINE SHOP: http://www.cafepress.com/sengokudaimyo
Grand Cross of the Order of the Laurel: http://www.cafepress.com/laurelorder
Custom avatars: http://sengokudaimyo.com/avatarbiz.html
SENGOKU DAIMYO ONLINE SHOP: http://www.cafepress.com/sengokudaimyo
Grand Cross of the Order of the Laurel: http://www.cafepress.com/laurelorder
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
The crossbow bolt holes are to deliberate and systematic to be battle damage, one was even shot through the inside of the helm and came out the top.
I suspect testing of outdated/no longer needed armor was fairly common.
The thickness measurements also show how much weight has been lost due to corrosion. Many of these helms probably had weight similar to a SCA helm when they were new.
I suspect testing of outdated/no longer needed armor was fairly common.
The thickness measurements also show how much weight has been lost due to corrosion. Many of these helms probably had weight similar to a SCA helm when they were new.
- RandallMoffett
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4613
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: SE Iowa
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
While that may be Buster there is nothing that proves that damage was done in testing or battle so either way people are guessing. While your theory of testing on outdated armour may be do you have evidence to show it was a common practice?
All I can find indicates this castle did not make it through the medieval period. Any who can read Moravian(?) might be able to find more out about the castle. I'd be unlikely it was that outdated by the 14th to take out and destroy for fun if the castle was indeed on the outs as a fortification by that point. As well being in a fill pit could just as likely mean it was damaged in battle as horseplay or practice...
I agree they likely were heavier but not sure we can be sure of thickness loss unless they did very highly detailed measurements like those of the 17th century breastplates the RA did years ago.
RPM
All I can find indicates this castle did not make it through the medieval period. Any who can read Moravian(?) might be able to find more out about the castle. I'd be unlikely it was that outdated by the 14th to take out and destroy for fun if the castle was indeed on the outs as a fortification by that point. As well being in a fill pit could just as likely mean it was damaged in battle as horseplay or practice...
I agree they likely were heavier but not sure we can be sure of thickness loss unless they did very highly detailed measurements like those of the 17th century breastplates the RA did years ago.
RPM
-
- New Member
- Posts: 45
- Joined: Tue Jan 24, 2012 8:15 pm
- Location: Ansteorra / Fort Worth
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
And this is a largely unschooled person's opinion, but if you wear your great helm over a better fitting, possibly better hardened interior helm, do you even care if you take a bolt to the edges of your barrel? Or do you just laugh maniacally at the archers (Assuming you are close enough) or giggle under your breath and keep on keeping on?
- Ironbadger
- Archive Member
- Posts: 3445
- Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 2:39 pm
- Location: Anaheim, southern California
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I had the exact same reaction myself. Eff.
-Badger-
-Badger-
Effingham wrote:As I look at that helm, I find myself immediately thinking, "Prank, without the wrapper."
Maker of sharp and pointy things!
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
It's not really a theory, just a guess.RandallMoffett wrote:While that may be Buster there is nothing that proves that damage was done in testing or battle so either way people are guessing. While your theory of testing on outdated armour may be do you have evidence to show it was a common practice?
All I can find indicates this castle did not make it through the medieval period. Any who can read Moravian(?) might be able to find more out about the castle. I'd be unlikely it was that outdated by the 14th to take out and destroy for fun if the castle was indeed on the outs as a fortification by that point. As well being in a fill pit could just as likely mean it was damaged in battle as horseplay or practice...
I agree they likely were heavier but not sure we can be sure of thickness loss unless they did very highly detailed measurements like those of the 17th century breastplates the RA did years ago.
RPM
The crossbow bolt hole that's been punched through the top from the inside can be safely ruled out as battle damage, and proves that at some point, someone shot it at least once while it wasn't being worn.
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
It's just speculation but from direct experience from the AA, testing scrapped armour is one of the most funny thing you can do with unsuitable pieces of junk. So, as stated several times on the AA that men didn't change in this shor timespan, we can guess that what is fun today was fun back then.RandallMoffett wrote:While your theory of testing on outdated armour may be do you have evidence to show it was a common practice?
RPM
- RandallMoffett
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4613
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: SE Iowa
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
"The crossbow bolt hole that's been punched through the top from the inside can be safely ruled out as battle damage, and proves that at some point, someone shot it at least once while it wasn't being worn."
Buster,
Not so. If a man falls on the ground or is knocked out of a saddle if his feet face the enemy or is climbing up a ladder to a castle it is possible to be shot from down up like that. A mounted man especially has more of a chance of being shot from someone lower than him as all/most archers would likely be on the ground.
In the end the idea they were destroying this with the bottom opening toward the shooter is rather odd. You'd much more likely sit it down and do it.
My point is it is just as likely either way and any making firm statements on what we have here are out on a limb. I think we can say they are perhaps made by bolt heads as a pole axe would have had more damage along the axis of impact but not much mroe than that.
Sig,
True enough.
RPM
Buster,
Not so. If a man falls on the ground or is knocked out of a saddle if his feet face the enemy or is climbing up a ladder to a castle it is possible to be shot from down up like that. A mounted man especially has more of a chance of being shot from someone lower than him as all/most archers would likely be on the ground.
In the end the idea they were destroying this with the bottom opening toward the shooter is rather odd. You'd much more likely sit it down and do it.
My point is it is just as likely either way and any making firm statements on what we have here are out on a limb. I think we can say they are perhaps made by bolt heads as a pole axe would have had more damage along the axis of impact but not much mroe than that.
Sig,
True enough.
RPM
- Effingham
- Archive Member
- Posts: 15102
- Joined: Sat Aug 19, 2000 1:01 am
- Location: Franklin, IN USA
- Contact:
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Randall, a guy on a battlement can also be shot from below.
Webpage: http://www.sengokudaimyo.com
Custom avatars: http://sengokudaimyo.com/avatarbiz.html
SENGOKU DAIMYO ONLINE SHOP: http://www.cafepress.com/sengokudaimyo
Grand Cross of the Order of the Laurel: http://www.cafepress.com/laurelorder
Custom avatars: http://sengokudaimyo.com/avatarbiz.html
SENGOKU DAIMYO ONLINE SHOP: http://www.cafepress.com/sengokudaimyo
Grand Cross of the Order of the Laurel: http://www.cafepress.com/laurelorder
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
It may be strong evidence that at the time that hole was made there was not a head inside - depending on things like angle of penetration, if it can be determined. It does not at all rule out battlefield damage, as it's entirely possible that after coming off someone's head it was hit by an errant bolt.Buster wrote:It's not really a theory, just a guess.RandallMoffett wrote:While that may be Buster there is nothing that proves that damage was done in testing or battle so either way people are guessing. While your theory of testing on outdated armour may be do you have evidence to show it was a common practice?
All I can find indicates this castle did not make it through the medieval period. Any who can read Moravian(?) might be able to find more out about the castle. I'd be unlikely it was that outdated by the 14th to take out and destroy for fun if the castle was indeed on the outs as a fortification by that point. As well being in a fill pit could just as likely mean it was damaged in battle as horseplay or practice...
I agree they likely were heavier but not sure we can be sure of thickness loss unless they did very highly detailed measurements like those of the 17th century breastplates the RA did years ago.
RPM
The crossbow bolt hole that's been punched through the top from the inside can be safely ruled out as battle damage, and proves that at some point, someone shot it at least once while it wasn't being worn.
As for making assumptions about them doing destructive testing on old armour - that we might think to do that sort of thing today does not mean that they would have considered it then. That sort of presumption really needs to be built on affirmative evidence that they did the thing, and not on the idea that you or I would naturally do it today.
Gavin Kilkenny
Proprietor
Noble Lion Leather
hardened leather armour and sundry leather goods
www.noblelionleather.com
Proprietor
Noble Lion Leather
hardened leather armour and sundry leather goods
www.noblelionleather.com
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I would not call it "destructive testing" but "Hey let's have fun with this crossbow and/or warhammer on this old junk, or "I bet a beer that I can hit this helm at 100 paces, at least 10 times in a row".
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Correct me if I wrong, but were these helmets not tossed off to dangle out of the way after closing? Is it not possible it took an arrow while on its chain?
Last edited by Dierick on Fri Nov 08, 2013 8:09 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 26725
- Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2001 1:01 am
- Location: Port Hueneme CA USA
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Possible, not provable, so imponderable.
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Bah, didn't realize I was reviving this thread.
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I might shoot the inside and I was doing destructive testing of the material the helm was made of. The interior is concave, and I don't have to worry quite as much about glances.RandallMoffett wrote: In the end the idea they were destroying this with the bottom opening toward the shooter is rather odd. You'd much more likely sit it down and do it.
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Resurrection
Now that we've gotten past the holes in the helmet, let's consider the similarities between this helmet from Dalecin Castle and the Madeln I. I think it's the same shop.
Now that we've gotten past the holes in the helmet, let's consider the similarities between this helmet from Dalecin Castle and the Madeln I. I think it's the same shop.
ferrum ferro acuitur et homo exacuit faciem amici sui
- Sean Powell
- Archive Member
- Posts: 9908
- Joined: Sat Jul 13, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: Holden MA
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
If not same shop then close enough to represent transfer of knowledge and style. Could be master and appretice or master and apprentices apprentice or it could just be the current local fashion. If I found 2 tunics with the same cut and style I wouldn't assume same seamstress/tailor.
Form does follow function. Anvils today look a lot like anvils 200 years ago. There are small variations but also small variations in breaths excetera that they aren't direct copies.
Sean
Form does follow function. Anvils today look a lot like anvils 200 years ago. There are small variations but also small variations in breaths excetera that they aren't direct copies.
Sean
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 39578
- Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2008 7:00 pm
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
There was a bascinet find that had been punctured by three bolts,including one from the inside. They speculated that the previous owner had been on the battlements and shot from the ground. I think the article was published by the Met, but it has been a while since I've read it, it might be in Held's A&A Annual.Buster wrote:The crossbow bolt hole that's been punched through the top from the inside can be safely ruled out as battle damage, and proves that at some point, someone shot it at least once while it wasn't being worn.
Vypadni z mého trávnÃk!
Does loyalty trump truth?
"If they hurt you, hurt them back. If they kill you, walk it off."- Captain America
Does loyalty trump truth?
"If they hurt you, hurt them back. If they kill you, walk it off."- Captain America
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I feel sure that this is the helmet to which Alcy is referring. This is a page from the Higgins armory catalog.
Mac
Mac
Robert MacPherson
The craftsmen of old had their secrets, and those secrets died with them. We are not the better for that, and neither are they.
http://www.lightlink.com/armory/
http://www.billyandcharlie.com
https://www.facebook.com/BillyAndCharlie
The craftsmen of old had their secrets, and those secrets died with them. We are not the better for that, and neither are they.
http://www.lightlink.com/armory/
http://www.billyandcharlie.com
https://www.facebook.com/BillyAndCharlie
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4777
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2001 2:01 am
- Location: North Carolina, USA
- Contact:
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
And that one just sold in the latest dispersal of the Higgins stuff. It was labeled as a fake. I expect Ian Eaves didn't label it that way lightly, it cost the sellers a good deal of money to have to sell a famous piece as a fake.Mac wrote:I feel sure that this is the helmet to which Alcy is referring. This is a page from the Higgins armory catalog.
Mac
So I would ignore any "evidence" provided by this piece.
Wade
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Thank you, Wade! I should have followed up on that.wcallen wrote:
And that one just sold in the latest dispersal of the Higgins stuff. It was labeled as a fake. I expect Ian Eaves didn't label it that way lightly, it cost the sellers a good deal of money to have to sell a famous piece as a fake.
So I would ignore any "evidence" provided by this piece.
Wade
If Ian Eaves thinks it's fake, it almost certainly is. I suppose it's too late to say that I always thought the shape of the helmet was a bit to "literal" and its fit a bit too close.
It does tell us something important about faking, though. The "romance" of this piece had carried it without question for a century. It's the little details that make us want to believe. Beware of things that are "too cool"!
Mac
Last edited by Mac on Sun May 18, 2014 10:34 am, edited 1 time in total.
Robert MacPherson
The craftsmen of old had their secrets, and those secrets died with them. We are not the better for that, and neither are they.
http://www.lightlink.com/armory/
http://www.billyandcharlie.com
https://www.facebook.com/BillyAndCharlie
The craftsmen of old had their secrets, and those secrets died with them. We are not the better for that, and neither are they.
http://www.lightlink.com/armory/
http://www.billyandcharlie.com
https://www.facebook.com/BillyAndCharlie
- RandallMoffett
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4613
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:01 am
- Location: SE Iowa
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I'd like to know why he decided that. It is not unheard of for things to be cast aside as fake and later found to be wrong.
RPM
RPM
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
I would like to know that too, Randal. I had the honor to be in the same Met-back-room with Ian some years ago. Toby C, Dirk B and I were looking at some things which were off display and under a haze of doubt. Ian was at the next table looking at some Greenwich stuff, but we periodically asked his opinion on the material we were examining. He has an astonishing ability to just "sense" a fake. Mostly, he can point to the problems and describe them, but other times is is just beyond words for him. Although that is a bit frustrating, I have a great respect for his intuition. If I had to trust someone's judgement on the question of authenticity, I would rather is was Ian Eaves' than almost anyone elses'.RandallMoffett wrote:I'd like to know why he decided that. It is not unheard of for things to be cast aside as fake and later found to be wrong.
RPM
Mac
Robert MacPherson
The craftsmen of old had their secrets, and those secrets died with them. We are not the better for that, and neither are they.
http://www.lightlink.com/armory/
http://www.billyandcharlie.com
https://www.facebook.com/BillyAndCharlie
The craftsmen of old had their secrets, and those secrets died with them. We are not the better for that, and neither are they.
http://www.lightlink.com/armory/
http://www.billyandcharlie.com
https://www.facebook.com/BillyAndCharlie
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4777
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2001 2:01 am
- Location: North Carolina, USA
- Contact:
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Not unheard of, no. But I expect if you did a study of "fakes pawned off as real" vs. "real called fakes and later determine to be real" the first would greatly outweigh the second. There just isn't a lot of money or prestige in the second. There is a lot in the first.RandallMoffett wrote:I'd like to know why he decided that. It is not unheard of for things to be cast aside as fake and later found to be wrong.
RPM
There is the obvious counter example of the Glasgow Kastenbrust. But that isn't this piece.
I didn't actually ask him about this one piece. I got the lucky chance to get Ian as my "man on the phone" at that sale, so I was able to ask followup questions about some of the items I was bidding on right then and there. The most illuminating was the pair of "1460 and later cuisses." He was pretty sure that a lot of the metal was 15th c. He just wasn't willing to to claim that any of the pieces you see looked like you see them now in the 15th c. I was expecting "well, the left cuisse is real, and maybe the right knee, the rest is made up" but he wouldn't go that far. He said that he had seen some of the pieces in Bashford Dean's collection that hadn't finished "restoration" when he died and it was amazing the things they would do. Anyway, he has enough experience with this stuff that I will let him have this one.
Wade
-
- Archive Member
- Posts: 4777
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2001 2:01 am
- Location: North Carolina, USA
- Contact:
Re: Great helm found in Moravia?
Actually, when I mentioned to Tom that it was up for sale and fake, he said he never did like the lines of it. I personally hadn't given it a lot of thought either way. Not pretty enough for me to really think about a lot.Mac wrote:
If Ian Eaves thinks it's fake, it almost certainly is. I suppose it's too late to say that I always thought the shape of the helmet was a bit to "literal" and its fit a bit too close.
Mac
Wade